What size should I get in Allen Edmonds Carlyle?

Shoe Fit calculates your millimeter shoe cavity to recommend your exact size in the Allen Edmonds Carlyle by comparing against shoes you already own.

Allen EdmondsUnisex

Carlyle

Fit verdict, size conversion guide, and millimeter measurements.

Find Your Size

Fit Analysis & Sizing Advice

Order 1/2 Size Up

This shoe runs approximately 1mm shorter than standard sizing. If you are between sizes or prefer a relaxed fit, go a half size up.

Runs Small (–8mm)True to SizeRuns Large (+8mm)

Snug / 1 Size UpStandard fitRoomy / 1 Size Down

Width: Narrow Fit. Tends to feel snug across the midfoot and forefoot. Wide-foot wearers should consider sizing up or looking for wide widths.

Community Fit Consensus

Aggregated feedback from verified shoe owners

4.4

(229 ratings)

75% of wearers report this shoe fits True to Size.

Length Distribution

Runs Small25%

True to Size75%

Runs Large0%

Width Distribution

Runs Narrow44%

Standard Width45%

Runs Wide11%

Complete Size Chart

Showing 21 sizes

EU	US (M)	UK	Foot Length	Cavity Length
36	3.5	3	22.4 cm	239 mm
36.5	4	3.5	22.7 cm	242 mm
37	4.5	4	23.1 cm	246 mm
37.5	5	4.5	23.4 cm	249 mm
38	5.5	5	23.7 cm	252 mm
38.5	6	5.5	24.1 cm	256 mm
39	6.5	6	24.4 cm	259 mm
40	7	6.5	25.1 cm	266 mm
40.5	7.5	7	25.4 cm	269 mm
41	8	7.5	25.7 cm	272 mm
41.5	8.5	8	26.1 cm	276 mm
42	9	8.5	26.4 cm	279 mm
42.5	9.5	9	26.7 cm	282 mm
43	10	9.5	27.1 cm	286 mm
43.5	10.5	10	27.4 cm	289 mm
44	11	10.5	27.7 cm	292 mm
44.5	11.5	11	28.1 cm	296 mm
45	12	11.5	28.4 cm	299 mm
45.5	12.5	12	28.7 cm	302 mm
46	13	12.5	29.1 cm	306 mm
47	14	13.5	29.7 cm	312 mm

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the Allen Edmonds Carlyle run big or small?

It tends to run slightly small. We recommend going a half size up for the best fit. This shoe runs approximately 1mm shorter than standard sizing. If you are between sizes or prefer a relaxed fit, go a half size up.

How does Shoe Fit determine shoe sizing?

Shoe Fit calculates the real-world interior shoe cavity in millimeters combined with real owner feedback, rather than relying on arbitrary brand charts.

Find Your Exact Size

Already own a shoe that fits well? Shoe Fit cross-references its internal cavity against the Allen Edmonds Carlyle to give you your personalized size.

Instant recommendation

Accounts for width & stretch

No sign-up required

Compare With Your Shoe

Model Details

BrandAllen Edmonds

ModelCarlyle

Gender SpecUnisex

Sizes Offered21 sizes

Community Rating4.4 ★ (229 votes)

Fit Data SourceCommunity Validated

Own this shoe?